PDA

View Full Version : SEO but to what degree?


reli4nt
10-27-2004, 02:29 AM
I have seen many troubling sites this week and been a part of several troubling conversations. They all centered around the issue of search engine optimization.

Everyone wants to rank number one in their respective keywords, but unless your business is based purely on page rank and position then it must be kept in mind that search engine optimization is just that; optimizing. It is a streamlining or culling of the fat that when taken too far will secure a high ranking but little to no consumer retention.

I think some businesses have lost sigh tof the fact that a site needs to be designed around the customer foremost, and the business second. It seldom seems reasonable to design or redesign a business site based solely on seo parameters, yet people keep asking for it.

In the end, I think its making us look bad. We as a whole are going to come out looking like the real estate agents who used to convince people to sell their old homes an purchase land in Florida; only for them to get there and find their new property is a swamp! Sure it's warm year round, off a major expressway and close to the beach, but a swamp is still just a swamp.

Any sight could do with some seo, and some need plenty of it. However, it is sad when the dollar signs light up in their eyes and the question of the degree to which seo is appropriate for the business and the consumer, never gets asked.

joker
10-27-2004, 08:09 AM
Search engines are one of the main sources of activity users in the Net, so conclusions about professional SEO should be made assuming this.

hugoguzman
10-27-2004, 11:45 AM
You pose an interesting question.

I for one am a big proponent of "natural" optimization. A website's usability, navigation, or design should never be compromised for the sake of SEO.

That is not a difficult thing to attain though. The most important SEO factors do not really alter the actual site anyway (backlinks with anchor text, interlinking structure, new pages of content). In the case of interlinking structure and adding new pages of content, they actually help to improve a site from the enduser's perspective. As for backlinks, the enduser is typically completely unaware of their existence.

Even most on-page factors are "invisible". The average internet user has no idea of what a metatag is.

eadpro
10-28-2004, 12:55 PM
I think that optimization, design, and usability go hand in hand.

Each aspect relies on the other.

reli4nt
10-28-2004, 09:10 PM
I think that optimization, design, and usability go hand in hand.

Each aspect relies on the other.


They should go hand in hand but some will sacrifice all the rest for the sake of one.

joker
10-29-2004, 03:55 AM
And the task of SEO professional is to make this mixture the most concorded